Kris Allen

I believe that Kris Allen’s victory on Wednesday night is a testament to America’s musical sensibilities. American Idol can be viewed as a thermometer of this country’s expectations and dreams for its music. And, interestingly enough, the winners aren’t always who you’d expect.

It would seem that every genre wants every other genre of music to think they’re on top. If I were asked (as a musician) which genre I thought dominated America’s playlists, I would easily have said pop; not just the ever-changing view of what’s ”popular,” but that synthesised teeny-bopper/diva music that seems to dominate the air waves and music television.

But American Idol keeps reinforcing the fact that America prefers a different flavor. There are slightly over 300,000,000 people in the U.S. American Idol received over 100,000,000 votes. Granted, one person may call in more than once, but that doesn’t undercut the observation that America has genuinely spoken.

Adam Lambert has talent and charisma oozing from every pore of being. Allow me to be transparent . . . I voted for Adam . . . 5 times. He has an amazing voice and a stellar stage presence, but I think he put too fine a point on his demographic. Kris, on the other hand, was never anyone’s favorite until the end. His vocals were underplayed, his stage presence reminded me of a shadow, and he pretty much flew under the radar the whole show. But his appeal became universal.

R&B didn’t win. Country didn’t win. And neither did Adam’s brand of Metal. Kris Allens smooth, vulnerable stylings crossed the genre pool and rose above it. There are a number of hit songs that unite people with the most extreme musical tastes, and Kris has done that as an artist.

As an alternative musician, I am brimming with pride that David Cook and Kris Allen have represented our country this way. Sure, I voted for Adam because (as an actor) I appreciate his raw talent and showmandship. But when I sit back and consider who I’m more likely to download onto my i-Pod . . . Kris wins every time.

I think that Kris has a long way to go to becoming a super-star. Simon is right, he need’s a little swagger, but despite his healthy dose of humility Kris’ message and delivery have clearly taken the day.

And America proves once again it knows good music.